One of the first questions I’m usually asked when discussing travel to Disney World is “Where should I stay?” I’d love to say that there’s a single answer that is right for everyone, but there really isn’t. I think the discussion comes down to one major question. Do you want to stay on property or off. There are pros and cons to each and I’m here to help you separate the two and make the decision that works best for you and your family.
Let’s start with staying on property, i.e. in one of the Disney owned resorts:
Staying on Disney property is a great experience and one that I recommend everyone try at least once. When you stay on property, it’s like the magic continues from the time you wake up until you go back to sleep. Disney resorts are well maintained and range from economical to luxurious. All the resorts are themed, and that theme extends to the smallest details. These are great and fun places to stay! The size of your room will vary directly with price, but all resorts have wonderful themed pools and dining areas as well. So let’s get to the details.

Disney’s All-Star Movies Resort – great theme and great price!
Pros
Great Disney themes
Disney transportation to all parks – You don’t need to ever get into a car after you arrive if you don’t plan to leave property.
Extra Magic Hours – Each day one of the parks either opens early or stays open late just for guests staying on Disney property. While this does make for smaller crowds during these hours, they can also increase the crowd during the day at those parks featuring extra hours since so many people plan their park visit around those hours. Trust me, though. It’s hard to beat the feeling of running into the Magic Kingdom past the crowd of people who won’t even get to walk through the gate for another hour.
No parking fees at the resort lots
No one does customer service like Disney – If anything isn’t to your liking, someone on staff will be happy to fix it for you. It really is a great experience. Everyone truly wants you to have a magical visit.
Cons
Price – In general, it does cost more for a room on Disney property than a comparable room elsewhere. Also meal prices on property are generally higher than off site.
Size – The rooms can be fairly small, especially in the lower priced resorts, if you’re traveling with multiple children. You may need to get more than one room, as a result.
Frankly, I don’t have a lot of cons other than the ones listed above. I LOVE staying in the Disney resorts and do it whenever possible. You’ll see below why that often isn’t an option, however.
Now let’s look at staying off property, i.e. one of the off property resorts or even in a rental house:
When traveling with MPH (My Poor Husband), our three children and usually our au pair or some of the grandparents, I’ve found it really too pricey to stay on property. Instead, I’ve started renting houses in the Kissimmee area which can be surprisingly economical. This gives us space for everyone to stay comfortably, and we’ve really enjoyed the experience.
Pros
Option to have a MUCH larger space – For larger families or groups traveling together, I highly recommend a rental house in the Kissimmee area. I can get a 4 bedroom house with a private pool and possibly even hot tub for the same per night rate as a moderately priced Disney resort single room. This then gives you the option to prepare meals at the house and save money on dining out.
Price – The rate for a rental house can be comparable to a single room rate on Disney property as noted above, but a single room rate at the off property hotels can be even lower. Some hotels even offer free transportation to and from the park. Meal rates off property are also usually lower which can add to your savings.
Getting Away – Sometimes it really is nice just to get away from the crowds and spend some time as a family doing something quieter than you usually do in the parks. Also, if you stay off property, it’s a bit of an incentive to find out what else the area has to offer, and that’s quite a bit. It’s easy to get from the same area to Universal Studios, for instance, for a day or two away from Disney.
Cons
Commute and parking – You will have a drive into Disney. This may just be 5 minutes, which really isn’t bad at all, but it can be longer depending on where you stay. If you stay in Orlando, count on it being fairly long. The traffic between Orlando and Disney World is heavy. Also there is a daily fee to park on Disney property. You can move your car from park to park without additional cost, but as of this writing, the fee is $14 per car and higher for a bus, camper or trailer. This really does add up! ***Special note: If any rider in your vehicle has annual pass, you may park for free! (This does not include the Florida resident annual pass.) Also parking is free at Downtown Disney. If you park here, you can use the Disney transportation from there to any park without charge.
No access to Extra Magic Hours – yes, you have to watch the park guests either walk past you to go into the park early or stay late when you have to leave.

Photo op at Downtown Disney
My take home message here is that there is a place to stay either on or around the Disney property for any budget and any size group. You just need to take a look at your budget and what you want most from your vacation experience to figure out the best place for you to stay. Also remember that there are ways to deal with any cons to any location. Just plan your trip, and get ready to have fun!